When navigating the complexities of family law, one common question arises: can legal fees paid in connection with a divorce be deducted from income for tax purposes? This article explores this issue, incorporating guidance from the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA), relevant legislation, and key case law.
General Rule: Legal Fees and Income Tax
The Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) specifies that legal fees incurred for personal or living expenses are not deductible unless explicitly permitted by the Income Tax Act. The deductibility of legal fees depends largely on their purpose. For family law matters, the distinction hinges on whether the fees relate to establishing , collecting, or defending spousal support or child support, or to other non-deductible purposes such as divorce, custody, or property division.
Deductible Legal Fees: Support Recipients
Legal fees incurred by a recipient of spousal or child support may be deductible if they meet certain conditions. Specifically, fees paid to:
Establish Support: Legal costs to negotiate or obtain spousal or child support from a former partner or parent.
Enforce Support: Legal fees to collect late or unpaid support payments.
Increase Support: Expenses to seek an increase in support payments.
Defend Against Reduction: Fees incurred to defend against a reduction in support.
These legal fees are considered necessary to enforce a pre-existing right to income, which qualifies them under paragraph 18(1)(a) of the Income Tax Act as being incurred to "gain or produce income from property" (e.g., support payments).
Notably, child support payments are typically non-taxable under current rules. But legal fees spent to establish or enforce child support are indeed deductible.
Non-Deductible Legal Fees
Legal fees are not deductible if incurred for:
Getting a divorce or separation;
Establishing custody/decision making responsibility or visitation rights for children;
Property division, equalization, or settlement; or
Defending a reduction in the payor’s spousal or child support obligations (for payors).
CRA views these costs as personal expenses, which do not meet the statutory requirements for deduction.
Key CRA Guidelines and Case Law
CRA's Approach
The CRA's position is that only legal fees incurred to enforce or protect or establish a 'pre-existing' right to income are deductible. For instance, costs to establish an entitlement to support are allowed (although the terminology does not fit exactly because spousal support is not presumed - the entitlement must be established by the one seeking it), but lawyer fees related to broader family law disputes, such as divorce or custody, are not tax deductible.
Case Law
In Nadeau v. M.N.R., 2003 FCA 400, the Federal Court of Appeal held that spousal and child support payments are "property" under the Income Tax Act, and legal fees incurred to enforce such rights are deductible.
In Grenon v. Canada, 2016 FCA 4, the Federal Court of Appeal reinforced that the purpose of incurring legal fees determines their deductibility.
CRA Form T1198:
If a retroactive lump-sum support payment includes arrears for previous tax years, CRA allows recipients to request tax relief by allocating the payment to the years it was intended. This can significantly reduce the tax burden.
How to Claim Legal Fees
To claim legal fees, recipients of support must:
Obtain Detailed Billing Statements: Ensure your lawyer provides an itemized account of services related to deductible legal work, such as establishing or collecting support.
Use CRA Form T1 General – Line 22100: Report deductible legal expenses on the specified line for spousal or child support legal fees.
Subtract Court Costs: If awarded court costs, these amounts must be deducted from the claimable legal fees.
Tax Implications for Support Payors
Legal fees incurred by payors, such as those related to negotiating or defending support obligations, are generally non-deductible. The CRA considers these costs to be personal and unrelated to producing income from property or business.
Lump-Sum Payments: Special Tax Considerations
In cases where spousal or child support arrears are paid as a retroactive lump sum, special rules apply. If the lump sum qualifies as a Qualifying Retroactive Lump-Sum Payment (QRLSP), recipients may request CRA to allocate the payment to prior years, potentially reducing the overall tax liability. Payors, however, cannot deduct these payments unless they are explicitly for arrears of periodic support under a domestic contract or a court order.
Conclusion
Understanding the nuances of legal fee deductibility in family law matters is essential for maximizing tax efficiency during or after a divorce. It's also important if you are considering going to court or you are already in court.
While support recipients may claim certain legal expenses, payors and others involved in broader family law issues may not enjoy similar benefits. Always consult with a legal or tax professional to determine the exact deductibility of legal fees in your circumstances.
If you have questions about the deductibility of legal fees or need assistance with family law matters, our firm is here to help. Contact us today for personalized guidance tailored to your situation.
Commenti