It was a cold January morning when Alex, a newly separated parent, came into his accountant's office. Alex had just finalized a separation agreement (e.g., domestic contract) to pay both spousal and child support to his former partner, Natasha. A natural question arose: Can I deduct these support payments from my income taxes?
This is a critical question for many navigating the financial complexities of separation and divorce. Let’s explore how the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) treats periodic (e..g, monthly) and lump-sum spousal and child support payments, referencing key legislation, CRA guidelines, and leading court cases.
Spousal Support: The Basics
The Income Tax Act (ITA) generally allows payers to deduct spousal support payments from their taxable income. However, to qualify as deductible, these payments must meet specific criteria:
Written Agreement or Court Order: Payments must be made under a formal written agreement or court order (ITA, Section 60).
Periodic Payments: The payments must be made on a periodic basis, such as monthly or quarterly. Lump sums typically do not qualify, except under certain circumstances (discussed below).
Maintenance of the Recipient: The payments must be for the maintenance of the recipient, not as part of property division.
Separation Requirement: The parties must be living apart due to a breakdown in their relationship at the time of payment.
The recipient of support must include the support payments as income under ITA, Section 56, ensuring symmetry in the tax treatment.
Case Example: Grenon v. Canada, 2016 FCA 4
In this case, the Federal Court of Appeal affirmed that spousal support is deductible to the payer and taxable to the recipient, provided the above criteria are satisfied. This clarity helps in distinguishing spousal support payments from other financial obligations between separated spouses.
Child Support: A Different Story
Unlike spousal support, child support payments made under separation agreements or court orders issued after May 1, 1997, are neither deductible to the payer nor taxable to the recipient. This non-deductibility rule was implemented to simplify tax treatment and eliminate disputes about deductibility.
Exceptions: Pre-1997 Agreements
Child support payments under agreements made before May 1, 1997, remain taxable and deductible unless:
The agreement is amended after May 1, 1997, to change the amount of child support.
Both parties file Form T1157 with the CRA to elect for the new rules to apply.
Lump-Sum Payments: Special Considerations
Lump-sum payments for support often fall outside the scope of deductibility. However, there are key exceptions:
Arrears of Periodic Payments: A lump sum paid to cover missed periodic payments can be deductible if:
The payments were enforceable under a written agreement or court order.
The arrears represent amounts that should have been paid periodically.
"Arrears" is a fancy legal word that means an amount of money that is owed from a contract or a court order and has not been paid by the payor.
The difference between arrears and "retroactive" is simply that a retroactive amount (also a fancy legal word) has not been agreed to and put in writing by the parties nor has it yet been found owing by a court and issued in an order. A retroactive amount is normally an amount that is still being disputed by the parties, and one party maintains that amount is owing.
Qualifying Retroactive Lump-Sum Payments (QRLSP): If the lump sum qualifies as a QRLSP under CRA rules, the payer may deduct it, and the recipient may spread the tax liability over prior years to which the payments relate. To facilitate this, the payer must complete CRA Form T1198.
Case Example: James v. Canada, 2013 TCC 164
The Tax Court allowed a deduction for a lump-sum payment covering arrears of spousal support, emphasizing that it represented unpaid periodic payments. This decision underscores the importance of documenting the nature of such payments.
Tax Forms and Documentation
Form T1158: Used to register family support payments with the CRA, ensuring tax compliance for both parties.
Form T1198: Required for recipients of QRLSPs to request tax relief by allocating the lump sum to previous years.
T1 General Return: Deductible spousal support is reported on Line 22000, while recipients report it on Line 12800. Non-deductible child support is reported separately to avoid confusion.
Key Legislative and CRA References
Income Tax Act, Section 60: Deductibility of spousal support payments.
Income Tax Act, Section 56: Taxability of spousal support payments.
Income Tax Folio S1-F3-C3: CRA’s guidelines on support payments, including QRLSPs.
Line 22000 and 12799: CRA’s tax return instructions for support payments.
Navigating the Tax Maze
For Alex, understanding the tax implications of spousal and child support payments brought clarity and relief because he learned he could, at least, deduct spousal support payments.
By structuring their support agreement to align with CRA rules and completing the necessary forms, Alex could optimize his tax position while ensuring compliance.
If you’re in a similar situation, consulting with both legal and tax professionals can help you avoid costly mistakes and maximize what you earn.
Have questions about your support payments? Contact our office for tailored advice and expert assistance.
Commentaires